About Key Group Benefits
Key Group Benefits is an independent insurance agency focused on helping individuals, families, and business owners make confident, well-informed decisions around property, casualty, life, and health insurance.
As an independent firm, we are not tied to any single carrier. Our role is to explain coverage clearly, compare real options, and design policies that fit how clients actually live and work.
Kyle Heafy
Managing Partner — Property & Casualty
kyle@keygroupwealth.com
201-448-9679
Kyle Heafy is a Managing Partner at Key Group Benefits and leads the firm’s Property & Casualty practice. His work centers on helping clients understand risk, coverage tradeoffs, and policy design in plain language.
Kyle oversees carrier relationships and overall coverage strategy to ensure recommendations remain practical, transparent, and aligned with real-world risk.
Brendan Heafy
Managing Partner — Life & Health
brendanh@keygroupwealth.com
201-604-2524
Brendan Heafy is a Managing Partner at Key Group Benefits and leads the firm’s Life & Health practice. He works with individuals, families, and business owners to design coverage that protects income, dependents, and long-term financial security.
His focus includes life insurance planning, health coverage, disability income protection, and Medicare guidance, helping clients navigate complex decisions with clarity and confidence.
Brendan also oversees service quality and internal processes to ensure clients receive knowledgeable, responsive support throughout the life of their coverage.
Ready to talk through your coverage?
We’ll walk you through options and next steps in plain English.